Safest Cars for Teens are Not the Stuff of Dreams

When I started high school in 1980 I was already aching to get my driver’s license. My dream car was a 1965 Citroen DS19.

sub
A few-years-old Subaru Outback is a safe choice for new teen drivers, the IIHS says.

But the French classic had never sold well in the U.S. so good examples were hard to find and replacement parts were nearly unobtainable on my lawn-cutting budget. Besides, nobody in my immediate social group wanted to talk about odd European cars. So I learned to covet the speedy Pontiac GTOs, Chevy Camaros and Ford Mustang convertibles that every other octane-afflicted boy wanted.

I wound up spending senior year at the wheel of a 1966 Mustang that I had spent the previous few years wrenching back to good health. Early Mustangs weren’t collector cars back then, but mine was reasonably stylish and cool by high-school standards, especially in the era of K-Cars and econoboxes.

IMG_20151015_150359
Based on the inscription, local high school seniors have taken over this 30-year-old Mercedes-Benz S-Class sedan that probably used to belong to Grandpa. No electronic stability control, but at least it is large and solidly built.

Turns out I probably would have been better-off in something larger, newer (but still used) and slower according to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Perhaps my father’s 1976 Chrysler Cordoba?

The organization, funded by the insurance industry and well-known for its demanding crash-test standards, recently published a new list of the vehicles it recommends for new teenage drivers. The roster, which has grown more than 50% since last year, reflects the wider availability of safety features like multiple airbags and electronic stability control at relatively low prices in the used-vehicle market compared with years past.

The list has two tiers, including the “best choices,” which cost less than $20,000 and received good ratings in the Institute’s four oldest crashworthiness tests. “Good choices” priced under $10,000 with less-than-perfect ratings in some tests, form the second tier.

citroen
My high school dream car, the Citroen DS19, was ahead of its time safety-wise but would not impress the IIHS today.

The IIHS says parents are headed in the right direction when shopping for teen cars if they avoid high-horsepower models; remember larger, heavier vehicles are safer than small, light ones; and look for models with electronic stability control.

Below is the full list of IIHS-recommended models and their average prices:

Best Choices: Large Cars

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Volvo S80 2007 and newer $5,800
Ford Taurus 2010 and newer $10,900
Buick LaCrosse 2010 and newer $11,300
Buick Regal 2011 and newer $11,500
Lincoln MKS 2009 and newer $12,300
Toyota Avalon 2011 and newer $15,700
Hyundai Azera 2012 and newer $16,800
Mercedes-Benz E-Class sedan and coupe 2010 and newer $19,000
Infiniti M37/M56/Q70 2011 and newer $19,900

Best Choices: Midsize Cars

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Volkswagen Jetta sedan and wagon 2009 and newer $5,600
Volvo C30 2008 and newer $7,000
Volkswagen Passat sedan 2009 and newer $7,300
Ford Fusion 2010 and newer; built after April 2010; 2010 Fusions built before May meet “good choice” criteria $7,400
Mercury Milan 2010-11; built after April 2010; 2010 Milans built before May meet “good choice” criteria $7,400
Chrysler 200 sedan 2011 and newer $8,000
Chevrolet Malibu 2010 and newer; built after November 2009 $8,200
Volkswagen CC 2009 and newer $8,300
Audi A3 2008 and newer $8,400
Dodge Avenger 2011 and newer $8,900
Subaru Legacy 2010 and newer $9,300
Hyundai Sonata 2011 and newer $9,900
Lincoln MKZ 2010 and newer; built after April 2010 $10,000
Kia Optima 2011 and newer $10,200
Audi A4 sedan 2009 and newer $10,800
Honda Accord sedan and coupe sedan 2012 and newer; coupe 2013 and newer $10,900
Subaru Outback 2010 and newer $11,300
Toyota Camry 2012 and newer $11,300
Nissan Altima 2013 and newer $12,200
Mercedes-Benz C-Class sedan 2009-14 $12,300
Buick Verano 2012 and newer $12,400
Volvo S60 2011 and newer (price is for 2012, which had lower trim level available) $13,400
Toyota Prius v 2012 and newer $14,200
Mazda 6 2014 and newer $15,100
Acura TSX sedan and wagon 2012 and newer $16,600
Acura TL 2012 and newer; built after April 2012 $17,300

Best Choices: Small SUVs

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Honda Element 2007-11 $6,700
Volkswagen Tiguan 2009 and newer $7,900
Subaru Forester 2009 and newer $9,000
Mitsubishi Outlander Sport 2011 and newer $9,300
Hyundai Tucson 2010 and newer $10,400
Kia Sportage 2011 and newer $11,300
Jeep Patriot 2014 and newer $13,700
Ford Escape 2013 and newer $14,000
Mitsubishi Outlander 2014 and newer $14,400
Mazda CX-5 2013 and newer $14,800
Honda CR-V 2012 and newer $15,400
Buick Encore 2013 and newer $15,500
Toyota RAV4 2013 and newer $17,600
Nissan Rogue (except Select) 2014 and newer $18,500

Best Choices: Midsize SUVs

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Volvo XC90 2005 and newer $4,600
Subaru Tribeca/B9 Tribeca 2006 and newer $6,000
Dodge Journey 2010 and newer $8,700
Chevrolet Equinox 2010 and newer $11,100
Ford Flex 2010 and newer; built after January 2010 $11,700
GMC Terrain 2010 and newer $12,000
Toyota Highlander 2008 and newer $12,000
Infiniti EX 2008 and newer $12,100
Toyota Venza 2009 and newer $12,200
Kia Sorento 2011 and newer $12,300
Ford Edge 2011 and newer; built after February 2011 $13,300
Volvo XC60 2010 and newer $13,500
Ford Explorer 2011 and newer $16,200
Lincoln MKT 2010 and newer; built after March 2010 $16,200
Dodge Durango 2011 and newer $16,300
Cadillac SRX 2010 and newer $16,900
Audi Q5 2009 and newer $17,300
Jeep Cherokee 2014 and newer $17,500
Honda Crosstour 2013 and newer $17,700
Honda Pilot 2012 and newer $18,200
Jeep Grand Cherokee 2011 and newer $18,500
Mercedes-Benz GLK-Class 2011 and newer $19,100

Best Choices: Large SUVs

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Chevrolet Traverse 2011 and newer $13,500
GMC Acadia 2011 and newer $15,400
Buick Enclave 2011 and newer $16,100

Best Choices: Minivans

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Dodge Grand Caravan 2012 and newer $11,600
Volkswagen Routan 2012 and newer $11,800
Toyota Sienna 2011 and newer $13,200
Honda Odyssey 2011 and newer $13,600
Chrysler Town & Country 2012 and newer $14,600

Best Choices: Pickups

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Toyota Tundra crew cab (Double Cab) 2007 and newer $12,200
Ford F-150 crew cab (SuperCrew) 2011 and newer $16,800

Good Choices: Large Cars

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Hyundai Azera 2006-11 $4,100
Audi A6 sedan 2005 and newer $6,000
Acura RL 2005-12 $6,700
Ford Taurus 2009 $7,100
Cadillac DTS 2008-11 $7,700
Mercury Sable 2009 $7,700
Chevrolet Impala 2011 and newer $8,700
Mercedes-Benz E-Class sedan 2007-09 and newer $8,800
Toyota Avalon 2009-10 $9,000
Lexus GS 2006 and newer $9,300
Cadillac CTS 2008 and newer $9,700

Good Choices: Midsize Cars

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Saab 9-5 sedan and wagon 2005-11 $2,700
Saab 9-3 sedan and wagon 2005-11 $2,800
Hyundai Sonata 2006-10 $3,300
Volkswagen Passat sedan and wagon 2006-08 $3,400
Audi A4 sedan and wagon 2005-08; built after October 2004 $4,200
Volvo S60 2007-09 $4,400
Suzuki Kizashi 2010-13 $4,500
Mercedes-Benz C-Class sedan 2005-08 $4,600
Acura TL 2004-12 $4,800
Saturn Aura 2009 $5,500
Volvo S40 2007 and newer $5,600
Audi A3 2006-07 $5,800
BMW 3-series sedan 2006 and newer $5,900
Mazda 6 2009-13 $6,600
Mitsubishi Galant 2010-12 $6,700
Chevrolet Malibu 2009-10 $7,200
Honda Accord sedan 2008-11 $7,200
Kia Optima 2010 $7,300
Subaru Legacy 2009 $7,700
Pontiac G6 sedan 2010 $7,800
Lincoln MKZ 2009-10; built before May 2010 $8,000
Nissan Altima 2010-12 $8,100
Lexus IS 250 2006 and newer $8,500
Toyota Camry 2010-11 $8,900
Infiniti G sedan 2007 and newer $9,000
Lexus ES 350 2007 and newer $9,600

Good Choices: Small SUVs

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Suzuki Grand Vitara 2006-13 $3,500
Mitsubishi Outlander 2007-13 $4,600
Mazda Tribute 2009-11 $5,700
Ford Escape 2009-12 $6,100
Nissan Rogue 2008-13 $6,900
Toyota RAV4 2007-12 $7,600
Honda CR-V 2007-11 $8,300
Mercury Mariner 2009-11 $8,400

Good Choices: Midsize SUVs

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Suzuki XL7 2008-09 $3,600
Mazda CX-7 2007-11 $5,000
Saturn Vue 2008-09 $5,000
Ford Taurus X 2008-09 $5,700
Honda Pilot 2006-11 $6,000
Hyundai Santa Fe 2007 and newer $6,400
Mazda CX-9 2007 and newer $6,600
Hyundai Veracruz 2007-12 $7,000
Ford Edge 2007-11; built before March 2011 $7,600
Mercedes-Benz M-Class 2006 and newer $9,000
Mitsubishi Endeavor 2010-11 $9,500
Ford Explorer 2009-10 $9,600
Ford Flex 2009 $9,900
Lincoln MKX 2007 and newer $9,900

Good Choices: Large SUVs

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Saturn Outlook 2008-09; built after March 2008 $7,800
Mercedes-Benz R-Class 2007-12 $8,500

Good Choices: Minivans

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Kia Sedona 2006 and newer $3,400
Honda Odyssey 2005-10 $4,100
Hyundai Entourage 2007-08 $4,400
Chrysler Town & Country 2008-11 $5,600
Dodge Grand Caravan 2008-11 $6,200
Volkswagen Routan 2009-11 $6,300

Good Choice: Pickup

  MODEL YEARS PRICE
Honda Ridgeline 2006-2014 $7,700

Source: Insurance Institute for Highway Safety

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s